On October 27, 2010, a design professional who had attended (and spoken at) the 1569 W6th Public hearing on Oct 19 and observed the staff presentation and Council vote on Oct 21, delivered a letter to the office of the Director of Planning, City of Vancouver. Details are below. We will report back when we hear any news on this topic, which we see as a test case for the way information is presented to Council and the public.
[Update: Brent Toderian, Director of Planning was fired on Jan 31, 2012. Mr. Toderian did not respond to the challenge nor attempt to even verify the terms of reference during the remainder of his employment with the city. We’ve been told that it was hoped a response from Mr. Toderian would have been able to clarify the intent of view protection policy in Vancouver]
[Stephen Bohus, BLA, is a concerned citizen, has a degree in landscape architecture, and has been working with 3D graphics, computer graphics, and modelling in urban design, landscape architecture and architecture for over 20 years]
PUBLIC CHALLENGE TO VANCOUVER’S DIRECTOR OF PLANNING
regarding 1596 W6th Avenue tower height rezoning impact on views from Broadway & Granville Street
27 October 2010
Dear Mr Toderian,
Who is right? Will you be able to see the newly approved 15 storey tower at 1569 W 6th Avenue from Broadway and Granville? Will this tower block views of any parts of the mountains from this intersection? In the Public Hearing (October 19) and Council discussion (October 21) City staff and the applicant indicated that the views won’t be affected, but I respectfully disagree.
Vancouver citizens will find the truth, of course, once the tower is built.
I maintain that a person will see an impact on the views to the mountains as indicated by the terms of reference (on reverse). I predict that the new tower will partially block existing views of the North Shore mountains from the intersection of Broadway and Granville.
Will you go on public record to say that the tower at 1569 W 6th will not block views from Broadway and Granville, as listed by the terms of reference?
This is an important fact that needs to be clarified for the public. Will you accept the challenge? If you would like to clarify any part of this challenge, please don’t hesitate to contact me.
Stephen Bohus, BLA
Terms of Reference for Challenge
Can a pedestrian, who can move freely around within this intersection (Broadway and Granville) see the new tower (1569 W 6th Street) from at least one point from grade up to 1.8 metres above grade?
An intersection is the area where two streets intersect; it is the area that the two streets have in common. This is illustrated in the diagrams. For quick reference, the intersection here is approximately the outer line of the four pedestrian crossings.
Assumption: no other new building will be built between lines of sight between 1569 W 6th and the intersection of Granville and Broadway before the construction is completed on the tower at 1569 W 6th.