Repeated failure to share power: Vision again grabs all 7 Vancouver seats on Metro Vancouver Board of Directors

(Updated) This is something we feel should attract media and public attention. Vision Vancouver has once again appointed only its own people to monopolize all seven Directors‘ seats representing the citizens of Vancouver on the Metro Vancouver Board. This is a problem because of the secrecy of Metro Vancouver in many of its practices, and the consistent failure of the Vision political machine to share Metro information with the rest of the elected members of City Council. Yet again today, after brief formalities, the Metro Vancouver Board meeting was closed to the public, so all but Board members were ejected from the room, and the live web video went dark.  Public business is being conducted without the requisite openness and transparency. And any information to the regional policy-making body and coming back to Vancouver’s City Council and the public is filtered through one political entity, at the expense of the public and citizens of this city.  (Reportedly, no audio or video record is kept of those in camera meetings, and there is no public assurance whether the requirements for going in camera are even met.) There is much talk of respect for diversity, but that same respect is needed for representation on the Metro Board.

During the December 9, 2015 Regular Council meeting Mayor Robertson brought forward a recommendation to again appoint all seats for Directors to Vision Vancouver Council members, as follows:
metro directors 2016

It would be an understatement to say that this is not a fair and equitable delegation from the City of Vancouver. How did Mayor Robertson choose the 6 Councillors who will join him on Metro Vancouver Board? Is it 100% completely partisan? By any indication, it does not reflect either the popular vote or even the results of the at-large election in 2014:

pie chart 2014 election vs metro

There is a major democracy deficit in the composition of Metro Vancouver Directors from the City of Vancouver. Rather than have Robertson decide to appoint all 6 Vision Vancouver Councillors to Metro, perhaps a slightly fairer approach would be to have been to instead go with 3 Vision, 2 NPA and 1 Green Councillor. Another alternate model would be to appoint the top vote getters:

elected not elected 2014 top 21

Under this scenario, Councillors Carr, Affleck, Ball, De Genova, Deal and Jang would fill 6 of the 7 posts for Metro Vancouver, with Robertson taking the final position (a point of reference is Victoria and the composition of the Capital Regional District).

While there are Alternate Directors for the Metro Vancouver Board, the alternates only attend Board Meetings when a Director is absent. This is of course assuming that the Alternate Director is even informed that a Director will miss the meeting (Directors have forgotten to tell their alternates a number of times of their absence). Alternate Directors are not allowed to be on Committee meetings (only Board Meetings), despite issues of compliance with provincial regulations.

The Inaugural Meeting for the 2016 Metro Vancouver Board will take place at 9am on Friday, December 11, 2015. The live broadcast of the meeting will be available on the Metro webpage.
Metro Vancouver video feed

After brief formalities, the Metro Vancouver Board meeting was closed to the public, so all but Board members were ejected from the room, and the live web video went dark:

metrovan 'live' broadcast

2 thoughts on “Repeated failure to share power: Vision again grabs all 7 Vancouver seats on Metro Vancouver Board of Directors

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s